Welcome back to my series on the great retirement book The Retire Sooner Method: The 5 Secrets Behind America’s Happiest (and Unhappiest) Retirees.
So far we’ve had the following posts in this series:
- The Retire Sooner Method: Overview
- The Retire Sooner Method: Overview, Part 2
- The Retire Sooner Method: Secret #1, The Money Green Zone
- The Retire Sooner Method: Secret #1, The Money Green Zone, Part 2
- The Retire Sooner Method: Secret #2, Core Pursuits
- The Retire Sooner Method: Secret #2, Core Pursuits, Part 2
- The Retire Sooner Method: Secret #3, Social Connections
- The Retire Sooner Method: Secret #3, Social Connections, Part 2
- The Retire Sooner Method: Secret #4: A Written Plan
- The Retire Sooner Method: Secret #5, The Happy Retiree Superpower of Sleep
- The Retire Sooner Method: Planning for Inflation
If you missed any of those posts, you’re going to want to go back and read them before you read this one, since today’s post is a continuation of the others.
Today we’re finishing up the series by discussing the book’s thoughts on investing before and in retirement.
The author begins this chapter by saying that while the previous parts of the book were based on research and data, this part is his opinion of how people should invest up to and in retirement based on his work with clients.
That’s an important distinction.
The five secrets were presented as findings from the research: what happy retirees tend to have or do differently than unhappy retirees. This chapter shifts into investment strategy. That doesn’t mean it’s not useful, but it does mean we should view it a little differently. This is less “the data says happy retirees do this” and more “here’s how Wes Moss thinks retirees can build an investment portfolio to support the kind of retirement the book has been describing.”
With that said, let’s get into it.
The Five Pillars of Income Investing
This chapter begins with what the author calls “The Five Pillars of Income Investing” which are as follows:
- Multi-asset-class income investing
- Dividend growth
- Dry powder principle
- The 4+ percent rule of thumb (you’ll remember this one from Chapter 2)
- Tax efficiency
I’m going to cover these briefly so you can get the general idea of what he’s saying, but if you want specifics, you’re going to have to get the book. This was a long chapter and there are many, many specifics to it.
But I’ll cover the highlights so you get the gist of it, as well as add in my thoughts as they will differ from his in spots.
That’s going to be especially true here because there are many ways to invest successfully. I don’t think there’s one perfect retirement portfolio for everyone. Your portfolio depends on your age, assets, income needs, spending level, risk tolerance, tax situation, Social Security, pensions, real estate, business income, and whether you actually need your portfolio to support your spending.
In my case, I’ve been retired for ten years and still haven’t needed to draw from my investment assets. That creates a very different mindset than someone who retires and immediately needs their portfolio to produce income.
So keep that in mind as we go through this.
Pillar #1: Multi-Asset Class Income Investing
We begin with Pillar #1. The books starts it off with this:
Let’s call this what it is: a balanced, simplified approach harnessing both G (Growth) and I (Income) that can work for you in the accumulation phase if you’re reinvesting dividends, and particularly well during retirement when you need cash flow.
One of the beauties of income investing is that, despite the name, it doesn’t force you to pick between growth or income. Income investing allows you to harness G and I by spreading your investments across multiple asset classes, each with its own way of generating cash and appreciation and compounding over time.
Basically he’s an advocate of a diversified set of investments that both grows and delivers income that compounds for years and decades to get you to retirement.
Then, when you retire it churns off a lot of income which helps you get to that $100k amount each year that happy retirees meet.
He advocates investments in these areas:
- Stocks
- Bonds
- Alternative Income (REITs, energy pipeline companies structured as master limited partnerships, preferred stocks, and closed-end funds)
- Cash (and Cash Equivalents)
- Commodities (including gold and silver)
Ok, that’s a pretty solid list and fairly standard (I would guess) among financial planners.
My approach was much simpler. I primarily used stocks, mostly index funds, real estate, and cash. It’s interesting to me that he doesn’t mention direct real estate here, as I know many people have gotten quite wealthy using it.
A few thoughts from me:
- I like the growth-plus-income framing, especially for retirees. Growth helps fight inflation and keeps the portfolio alive over a long retirement, while income can reduce the need to sell assets at bad times.
- I’m less interested in making the portfolio overly complex. Stocks, cash, and real estate worked very well for me, and I never felt the need to add a lot of extra categories just because they were available.
- I understand why planners like multi-asset approaches. They can smooth returns, provide different income streams, and help people stay invested during rough markets.
- But I also think simplicity is underrated. The more moving parts you have, the more you need to understand, monitor, rebalance, and manage.
- For many people, a relatively simple portfolio plus good spending control may work better than a complicated strategy they don’t fully understand.
That said, Moss is trying to build an income-focused retirement portfolio, and for that purpose, the broader asset list makes sense.
That said, I do have some issues with an income-focused strategy in the accumulation phase, which we’ll get into next.
The DID Principle: Dividends, Interest, Distributions
The above said, Moss is an advocate for an investment strategy that focuses a bit more on income than you might see elsewhere, especially in the accumulation phase.
He advocates for what he calls the “DID principle,” which stands for:
- Dividends: Companies sharing profits as cash with shareholders. When you own dividend-paying stocks, you get a periodic check that represents your slice of the company’s success.
- Interest: The cash flow you earn for lending money (buying a bond) from the issuer, owning a CD, or keeping cash in high-yield accounts. This is your “reward” for essentially being the bank.
- Distributions: Payments from vehicles like REITs, pipeline companies, closed-end funds, private equity, and private debt. These often come monthly or quarterly and represent cash flow from the underlying assets.
One of the reasons I love multi-asset-class income investing is that it checks three important boxes, all at the same time: diversification, asset allocation, and balance.
As I said, it’s a bit more focused on income in the accumulation phase than most people are used to.
Generally, I think growth is the focus in the accumulation years. Then it can switch to an income/growth focus in retirement.
My thoughts:
- During my accumulation years, I didn’t need more taxable income. My earned income was already high, and extra dividends, interest, and distributions would have created more taxes.
- That’s one reason I preferred growth-oriented stock index funds. I wanted the value to compound, not necessarily kick off taxable income every year.
- I understand the appeal of income investing because it feels tangible. You see cash coming in, and that can be psychologically helpful.
- But investors need to remember that total return matters too. A portfolio that produces income but grows slowly may not be better than a portfolio with lower income but stronger long-term appreciation. Note that Moss advocates both growth AND income, so he’s not ignoring growth, but when income is taxed it’s going to be difficult to get a higher total return than a pure growth strategy IMO.
- In retirement, income becomes more attractive because you may actually need cash flow. That’s where dividends, interest, distributions, Social Security, pensions, rental income, and other sources can all play a role.
So I don’t disagree with the DID principle, but I would probably apply it differently depending on the stage of life.
In the accumulation stage, I lean more toward growth and tax efficiency.
In retirement, I can see shifting more toward income, especially for people who need portfolio cash flow to support spending.
Bucket System
To manage these investments and keep the straight, he has what he calls The Retire Sooner Method Bucket System. His four buckets are:
- Cash Bucket (Typically 5-10 Percent of Portfolio)
- Income Bucket (Typically 20-50 Percent of Portfolio) — This is your bond headquarters: government bonds, municipal bonds, corporate bonds, and maybe a touch of high-yield.
- Alternative Income Bucket (Typically 5-15 Percent of Portfolio) — Here’s our eclectic team — the investments that don’t fit neatly into traditional categories but still generate regular cash payments. REITS, energy pipeline companies, preferred stocks, and closed-end funds live here. These often deliver higher yields than traditional stocks and bonds, while adding diversification to your portfolio. As mentioned, we could throw PE, private debt, and venture capital in here, too.
- Growth Bucket (Typically 40-75 Percent of Portfolio) — This bucket is chock-full of stocks.
For me personally, I’d ramp up the growth bucket at the expense of the income and alternative buckets.
I’d also add real estate to the mix, which can provide both income and growth.
But this is his first pillar, not mine! Hahaha.
A few thoughts on buckets:
- I like the bucket concept because it helps retirees understand what each part of the portfolio is supposed to do. Cash is for short-term needs and peace of mind. Income assets are for cash flow. Growth assets are for long-term appreciation and inflation protection.
- The danger is making the buckets too rigid. Money is money, and sometimes people can get too attached to the labels rather than looking at the portfolio as a whole.
- I would be cautious with some of the alternative income assets unless you really understand them. REITs are fairly common, but MLPs, preferred stocks, closed-end funds, private equity, and private debt all come with their own issues.
- Higher yield often means higher risk, more complexity, or less liquidity. Sometimes it means all three.
- I’m not against these investments across the board, but I would not jump into them simply because they generate income.
As usual, the question is not “Can this investment produce income?” The question is “Does this investment fit my plan, risk tolerance, tax situation, and need for simplicity?”
For many retirees, a simpler version of the bucket system may be enough.
Pillar #2: Dividend Growth
Again, he’s going to focus a lot more on income in the accumulation stage than I (and probably most folks) would.
Here are his thoughts:
I like to think of dividends as the reliable paycheck of your portfolio.
And dividend growth? That’s your raise — not just this year but for the next ten, twenty, even thirty?
This is why dividend growth investing is one of the most powerful tools available to retirees. It’s not just about creating a stable income stream→ it’s about crafting an income stream that gets larger and more reliable the longer you stick with it. It’s the ultimate antidote to the sneaky corrosion of inflation, which slowly but surely chips away at the value of the dollars sitting in your wallet. Dividend income, especially when it grows, acts as a built-in cost-of-living adjustment
Dividend growth investing is designed to transform your portfolio into a compounding machine one that sits quietly in the corner, giving you a raise every year while you go about living your life. Your money essentially asks itself for a raise and then tells itself yes.
My thoughts:
- This would have meant a lot of extra taxes for me when I was in the accumulation phase, which is why I stuck mostly with growth investments like stock index funds. I didn’t need more income because my income was already high and taxed quite a bit.
- We do have a mentor in the forums who has used this strategy with quite a bit of success, so I know it can be done and done well. But he’s a super-intelligent and disciplined investor, so I think he’s more the exception than the rule.
- I do like dividend stocks later in life, once you’re entering or already in retirement, as they can help make up that $100k in income that happy retirees need every year.
- Dividend growth is especially attractive if you can build an income stream that rises over time. That helps offset inflation and can give retirees confidence that their income won’t stagnate.
That said, I’m not a dividend purist.
I know some investors love dividends because they feel like “real” income, while selling shares feels like “touching principal.” I understand the emotional difference, but from a total-return perspective, the distinction is not always as meaningful as people think.
If a company pays a dividend, the stock price generally adjusts for that. You received cash, but the company also has less cash. There’s no magic there.
Still, the psychology matters. If dividend income helps retirees stay calm, avoid selling in panic, and stick with a reasonable portfolio, that has value.
Pillar #3: Dry Powder Principle
Next Moss shares his third pillar:
One of the biggest risks for retirees isn’t market volatility itself — it’s how we react to it. Remember that loss aversion research we talked about earlier? The pain of losing money feels about 2.5 times stronger than the joy of gaining it. That’s why bear markets, even though they’re historically shorter and less frequent than bull markets, can feel absolutely overwhelming and drive us to make terrible decisions.
This is where the dry powder principle comes in: having at least three years’ worth of spending money above your guaranteed income streams, like Social Security and pension, in safety assets. If you need $100,000 a year and you’re getting $50,000 from guaranteed income streams like Social Security, your annual portfolio withdrawal need is $50,000. Multiply this by three, and you would want at least $150,000 in dry powder.
What makes up the dry powder is safe, liquid, high-quality bonds, but it could also include cash and money market funds. These bonds can be short- to intermediate-term US Treasuries, high-quality municipal bonds, or investment-grade corporate bonds. It’s not there to dazzle you with growth or generate exciting returns. They are there to give you confidence and breathing room when the stock market inevitably takes a hit.
Then, the market suddenly drops 20 percent or more — which happens roughly every three to five years, by the way. It you were invested purely in stocks, and you needed more than just your dividend income to cover your monthly spending, you’d face a tough choice: sell your shares at depressed prices to generate the cash you need for groceries and mortgage payments, or risk going without the cash flow that keeps your Alexa-activated lights on. Either way, the emotional strain becomes heavy.
But with dry powder, you have options. You can draw from the bond bucket while you patiently wait for the stock portion of your portfolio to recover. This keeps you from having to sell stocks at exactly the wrong time-which is what destroys most people’s long-term returns.
In other words, bonds buy you patience. And patience might be the most powerful investment tool you can have.
My thoughts here:
- In general, I’m in agreement with this line of thinking. BTW, notice that we’re now talking more about time in retirement. In theory, when you’re working and accumulating, you won’t need as much of a cushion because you have your job income.
- It’s true that people are often their own worst enemies. They tend to panic at exactly the wrong time, sell after the market has already dropped big-time, then hold cash because they “know” the market is about to tank again. Then they miss the inevitable run-up that follows a decline and are afraid to invest back in because valuations are “too high.” If they had simply ridden out the storm, they likely would have been fine.
- In retirement, even if you can avoid doing something stupid like that, you still may need to sell investments as part of funding your retirement. And you don’t want to sell when the market is down. Having a nice cash buffer keeps you from doing that. You can use the cash and wait out the market decline.
- I personally keep way more than what he’s suggesting in cash. We have several years of expenses in cash if we keep our current level of spending. If we had problems and needed to tighten the purse strings, we could probably spread that money out to almost a decade.
- Yes, I know this is not optimal, but as I’ve said before, I’m way past trying to optimize every part of my finances. This is a time when I’m ok with “good enough” and then being comfortable with that.
- I’ve already said I retired too late, which was a mistake. But one advantage of retiring late, and having income in retirement, is that we saved way more than needed and can afford to keep more cash than we could if we needed to optimize every dollar.
This is one of those places where spreadsheets and real life can differ.
A spreadsheet might say I should keep less cash and invest more. Over the long term, that would likely produce a higher expected return.
But peace of mind has value too.
If holding extra cash helps you sleep well, avoid panic, and live your life without constantly worrying about market moves, that may be worth the opportunity cost, especially if you already have more than enough.
At some point, the goal is not to win the spreadsheet contest.
The goal is to live well.
Last Two Pillars
I’m going to skip over the last two pillars, at least in detail, but I will share them.
Pillar #4 is “The 4+ Percent Rule of Thumb.”
We covered this quite extensively in an earlier part of this book, so there’s no use going through it again. The basic idea is that retirees can use a withdrawal-rate guideline, starting around 4% and possibly a bit higher, to turn assets into income without creating an unreasonable risk of running out of money.
I still use 4% as a general rule of thumb, though I understand why some people may use 4.5% or even a bit more depending on age, flexibility, asset allocation, Social Security, pensions, and spending patterns.
Pillar #5 is “Tax Efficiently.”
You can read what the book says if you want, but this is often such a personalized issue that generalities don’t work as well as people think.
I will say that it’s interesting that he addresses taxes as one of his pillars when his overall strategy is much heavier on income than most, and we know how income is taxed versus unrealized capital gains. 😉
And with that, we’ve finished the investing chapter.
Wrapping Up the Book and the Series
Since this is the last post in this series, let’s step back and summarize what we’ve covered.
Overall, I liked The Retire Sooner Method quite a bit. That shouldn’t be a surprise since I’ve spent this many posts writing about it. I don’t do long series on books I think are weak, repetitive, or not useful.
What I liked most is that the book is not simply another retirement finance book. There are already plenty of those.
This book certainly addresses money, and money is Secret #1 for a reason. If you’re constantly worried about running out of money, your retirement happiness is going to suffer. Having enough liquid investable assets, multiple income sources, a paid-off or nearly paid-off mortgage, and a reasonable withdrawal strategy can go a long way toward reducing financial stress.
But the book doesn’t stop with money. That’s what makes it valuable.
The book argues that happy retirement is built on several pillars working together:
- You need enough money to feel secure and free.
- You need enough core pursuits to give your days meaning, enjoyment, activity, and structure.
- You need enough social connection to avoid isolation and build a life with people who matter.
- You need enough planning to reduce uncertainty and give yourself a roadmap.
- You need enough sleep to support your health, energy, decision-making, relationships, and overall enjoyment of life.
Notice the key word: enough.
That might be the biggest takeaway from the entire book.
Not the most money. Not the most activities. Not the most friends. Not the most detailed financial plan. Not the most sleep.
Enough.
Enough is a very powerful concept in retirement. It’s also one that many people struggle with because they spend their working years chasing more. More income, more promotions, more savings, more investments, more accomplishments, more status, more stuff. Then they reach retirement and may not know how to shift from “more” to “enough.”
But retirement happiness depends heavily on making that shift.
At some point, more money does not add much to your life. More activities can make you over-scheduled. More social commitments can become exhausting. More planning can turn into needless tinkering. Even more sleep is not the goal if you’re already getting what your body needs.
The goal is to build a retirement that works.
For me, many of the book’s findings lined up with my own experience:
- We had more than enough financially when I retired, and that removed a huge amount of stress.
- I had several core pursuits already in place, including exercise, writing, reading, and eventually pickleball, ESI Money, and MMM.
- I had close family connections and have added more casual and activity-based connections over time.
- I had a solid financial plan, though my life plan evolved more through curiosity and experimentation.
- My sleep improved dramatically once I retired and my mind was no longer constantly dealing with work.
So yes, I’m probably a textbook example of many of the book’s principles.
That said, I didn’t agree with everything.
A few areas where I had questions or differences:
- I still think some of the numbers need personal interpretation. $1 million in investable assets, $100k in income, five core pursuits, five close friends, and so on are useful benchmarks, but they are not universal laws.
- I think the distinction between close friends and casual connections deserved more discussion. Not every relationship needs to be deep to improve retirement.
- I’m not a fan of the name “Rich Ratio,” though the underlying calculation can be useful.
- I wouldn’t personally build an income-heavy portfolio during the accumulation phase, especially if it creates unnecessary taxes.
- I prefer a simpler investment approach than the one outlined in the final chapter, though I understand why an income-focused strategy appeals to many retirees.
But these are mostly disagreements around details, definitions, and personal preferences.
The big picture is strong.
If I were to summarize the book in my own words, I’d say this:
A happy retirement is not created by money alone, but money gives you the freedom to build the rest of it. Once the financial foundation is solid, you need to intentionally create a life filled with meaningful activities, relationships, structure, adaptability, health, and rest. The happiest retirees are not drifting through retirement. They have enough money, enough purpose-filled activity, enough connection, enough planning, and enough sleep to enjoy the freedom they worked so hard to earn.
That’s a pretty good message.
It’s also very consistent with what I’ve said on ESI Money for years. Retirement is not just about escaping work. It’s about buying your life back and then actually doing something worthwhile with that life.
The money part matters. Earn, save, and invest well enough and long enough, and you can create the financial freedom to retire. But after that, the question changes.
It’s no longer, “Can I retire?”
It becomes, “How do I live well now that I can?”
That’s where many people fall short. They spend decades planning the money side and almost no time planning the life side. Then they retire and wonder why they feel bored, lonely, anxious, or unfulfilled.
This book is a good reminder that the non-financial side of retirement deserves serious attention too.
For those who are not yet retired, I’d suggest using this book as a checklist:
- Are you on track financially?
- Are you building multiple income sources?
- Are you working toward paying off your mortgage?
- Do you understand your withdrawal strategy?
- Do you have core pursuits you can expand in retirement?
- Are you testing retirement activities before you retire?
- Do you have enough close social connections?
- Are you building casual and activity-based relationships too?
- Do you have a written financial plan, even a simple one?
- Do you have a life plan for how you’ll spend your time?
- Are you protecting your sleep and health now?
If you’re already retired, I’d use the book as a diagnostic tool:
- If you’re happy, which of these secrets are already working for you?
- If you’re not as happy as you expected, which area is weak?
- Do you need more financial confidence?
- More activities?
- More people?
- More structure?
- Better sleep?
- More flexibility?
- Less worry?
Sometimes improving retirement happiness may not require a massive overhaul. It may simply require strengthening one or two weak areas.
Maybe you need another core pursuit.
Maybe you need a regular social activity.
Maybe you need to stop obsessing over your portfolio.
Maybe you need to finally build a written plan.
Maybe you need to go to bed at a consistent time.
Maybe you need to admit you have enough and start enjoying it.
That last one may be the hardest for many ESI Money readers. If you’re good at earning, saving, and investing, you may also be good at delaying gratification, optimizing, planning, and pushing for more. Those are excellent wealth-building traits. But they can become barriers once the wealth is built.
There comes a point where the wisest move is not to keep grinding. It’s to live.
That’s one of the reasons I appreciated this book. It encourages people to think not only about retiring sooner, but about retiring better. And as I’ve said many times, those extra years matter. The next year of your life is likely one of the best remaining years of your life physically. If you have enough money and enough of a plan, trading that year for more money you don’t need may not be a good deal.
So my conclusion is simple: I recommend the book.
It’s practical, research-based, easy to read, and focused on what actually seems to make retirees happy. You may not agree with every number, every definition, or every recommendation, but you will almost certainly find ideas that help you think more clearly about your own retirement.
And if nothing else, it should remind you that retirement is not one decision. It’s a life.
Build it accordingly.

Leave a Reply